by Gideon Lasco
Three days ago, the PHILIPPINE DAILY INQUIRER ran an article headlined "Mt. Pulag off limits to trekkers". Today, the same news was recycled, this time saying that Mt. Apo too is being closed. Neither is true. Mt. Pulag is wide open and my contacts in Mt. Apo say that although a move is being contemplated, it has not yet been formalized. In the case of Mt. Pulag, although the Kabayan town council wants to close the park, they cannot do so because they only control part of the park. In fact, most visitors who go to Mt. Pulag don't even get to reach Kabayan because the most commonly used trail (Ambangeg) only passes by the town of Bokod. As of now, the PAMB sees no reason to close the mountain. The forest fires
Although the same INQUIRER article acknowledges the DENR statement that only a PAMB decision is binding, why did they headline the article contrary to the content of their news? Sure, a headline that says "Mt. Pulag is closed" would attract more attention, but is this how news is being done nowadays? This irresponsible news is not only an academic violation. It has implications to real people.
Indeed, the perception of Mt. Pulag's closure is beginning to affect a lot of individuals. Many Kalanguya high school students depend on the income from their guiding on weekends as a means of sustaining their education. And since a bulk of visitors come during summer, they look forward to this season as a way of earning hard-earned money. Since newspapers barely reach their town, they were surprised, shocked, and really distressed to hear that a lot of people think that the park is closed when in fact they are waiting and ready to receive and guide visitors.
There are also medical missions and related projects being planned for Mt. Pulag this summer. Now the organizers are contemplating on cancelling their plans because of the said closure. Of course, the potential beneficiaries of this act of goodwill would be on the losing end.
Then there are also mountaineers who look forward to visiting one of the country's most beautiful mountain. They too are asking if the news is true, they've booked their flights already, they've filed their leaves.
All because of an irresponsible, misleading news article.
The issue here goes beyond the merits of closing Mt. Pulag. The fact is, Mt. Pulag is still open, and responsible media ought to be reporting facts, not catchy headlines. Until such time that the PAMB decides the close Pulag (if at all they will), reporting otherwise is a gross violation of journalistic ethics.
I am calling on the Philippine Daily Inquirer to rectify their misleading news article on Mt. Pulag. You are still the most respected newspaper in the country. Do not disappoint us.
Tuesday, March 16, 2010
Please spread the word: Irresponsible INQUIRER articles saying that Pulag is closed beginning to affect Kalanguya tribes. This is not true! Mt. Pulag is open.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

10 comments:
I hope you have directly contacted Inquirer. They quickly respond naman to comments on their articles. They should print an erratum ASAP!
You may send your feedback to Inquirer via this link:
http://services.inquirer.net/feedback/feedback.php?sendTo=regions
yanma
STOP KILLING JOURNALISTS!
STOP KILLING LOCALS LIVELIHOOD!
GILBERT,
Rae, mayan, yes of course I also sent feedback containing many of the points I raised here and in an earlier post.
Nonetheless, I am also posting this in my blog because I believe this is a teachable moment. ideally, responsible reporting would not even require feedback because it is a given that a journalist should get the whole picture by getting all sides.
Moreover, I don't want mountaineers to remain confused about the real state of Mt. Pulag.
I prefer closing Mt. Apo during the Holy Week period only. I have experienced this crowd during this time of year.
http://pinoyapache.blogspot.com/2009/01/apo-sandawa-playground-of-gods.html
Our friend Julius at the Santa Cruz tourism office told me last week, the same day that the Inquirer published the erroneous Pulag article, that they were considering imposing a cap on the number of trekkers on Mount Apo at any one time during this El Nino phase, equivalent to the estimated maximum carrying capacity of the mountain. However, they have not imposed any ban that I know of.
He said there have been no reported fires on Apo since the dry spell began. The park rangers at Kitanglad and Dulang-Dulang also said there have been no fires there either.
/Cecil
Sir Gid,
We are climbing Mt. Pulag this Holy Week. After contacting Ms. Emerita Albas (Mt. Pulag Superintendent) we received confirmation that Mt. Pulag is open. However, there will be a deliberation this Friday, March 18, between DENR and the LGU's on whether they will close it or not. Please send a reaction paper to mossyorchid@yahoo.com (Ms. Emerita) on why the park should NOT be closed to the public.
thank God it's not true. we'll be climbing pulag this holy week. hope this nonsense stops. there are still people needed to see the beauty of the mountain. and i vote that the mountain should not be closed!
Gideon,
Unfortunately, I spoke w/ Berry Angao, the local tourism office of Kabayan last night and it seems that they did pass an "ordinance" that will not allow climbers inside Mt Pulog Nat'l Park for so many reasons which I doubt are true. This was done w/o the consent of PAMB who has true jurisdiction over the National Park. I believe this was what PDI picked up and published.
Anyway, in support of PAMB, I have posted the same concern in my facebook site http://www.facebook.com/juanch. If you support PAMB, please leave a comment in my status so Merin Albas can print it and show the LGUs during their dialogue this Friday.
Thanks
The interest of the mountains should come first. If what they need is a break from our heavy footsteps and from our presence, then let that be. When the mountains are ready, they will call us back.
Post a Comment